Skip to main content
Vasion
PRODUCT COMPARISONS

Compare Print Management Software Alternatives

The right print management platform depends on your printers, identity system, security requirements, and the work your IT team wants to stop doing. A single feature checklist cannot tell you how much infrastructure you will keep, how users will release sensitive documents, or what a migration will involve. This guide offers a practical way to compare the options, then points you to the deeper product comparisons.

Start With Your Deployment Model

Ask where jobs travel and what must run at each site. PrinterLogic uses centrally managed direct IP printing to help organizations remove traditional print servers. Microsoft Universal Print is a cloud service: Universal Print-ready devices connect directly, while other printers can be connected through a Windows connector. Pharos Cloud also positions its platform around serverless management, direct IP printing, and secure release. PaperCut Hive is a cloud-native offering; PaperCut MF is a different, self-hosted product. That distinction matters more than a broad “cloud versus on-premises” label.

Print Management Comparison at a Glance

Use the questions below as the evaluation matrix for a shortlist. Record each vendor’s answer for your own fleet and contract, since a capability can depend on device model, integration or configuration.
Deployment
Can you retire print servers? What connector, agent or site service remains? How does printing behave if a connection is unavailable?
Fleet Fit
Which existing printer models, drivers, labels, operating systems, and locations are supported without replacement?
Security
How do users authenticate, where are held jobs stored, which release methods work on your devices, and what audit data is available?
Operations
Who deploys queues and drivers, manages exceptions, updates policies, and supports remote employees?
Cost and Migration
Who deploys queues and drivers, manages exceptions, updates policies, and supports remote employees?

How To Choose a Print Management Platform

First, inventory printers, locations, and applications that generate print jobs. Next, identify the documents that require secure release and the identity methods employees can use. Then run the same pilot with shortlisted vendors: deploy a printer, print from each supported endpoint, release a held job, recover from a network interruption, and inspect the admin reporting. Finally, calculate total cost using licenses, any extra volume, hardware, migration, and support time.
For organizations replacing servers across many sites, enterprise print management and serverless print infrastructure explain Vasion’s approach. If protected documents are the priority, review secure print management.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best alternative to PaperCut?
There is no universal winner. The answer depends on whether you use PaperCut MF or Hive, your device fleet, your print volume, and your need to retire existing infrastructure. Compare those requirements in a pilot rather than choosing by a feature count.
Is serverless printing the same as cloud printing?
No. Cloud printing describes where management or job delivery happens; serverless printing describes an architecture that removes traditional print servers. A cloud-managed product may still require a connector or site-side component for particular devices and workflows.
Can Microsoft Universal Print handle older printers?
Yes, many existing printers can be connected using Microsoft’s Windows-based Universal Print connector. Check compatibility and the operational requirements for your fleet.
What should regulated teams test?
Test authentication, secure release, job storage and retention, audit exports, administrator permissions, and evidence of relevant certifications. Verify the details for the deployment and devices you will actually use.
All product names are trademarks of their respective owners.
Source: G2.com, Inc, data as of 4/3/2026